Why not the Silicon Valley?

A while back, a colleague was faced with an author who wanted to say the Silicon Valley rather than just Silicon Valley because, after all, we say the Ottawa Valley.

But the Ottawa Valley is the Ottawa Valley because it’s the valley of the Ottawa River. I grew up in the Bow Valley, so called because it was the valley of the Bow River. There is no Death River and no Silicon River; the names Death Valley and Silicon Valley are not descriptive formations based on some geographic feature. A valley doesn’t need to have a river to get a “the,” but the “the” generally indicates a central geographic feature contained by the valley, and that geographic feature is the focal detail, not the valley – the valley is presented as a surrounding attribute.

On the other hand, places named after some feature or associated quality or thing such that the place, not the associated thing, is central (and the associated thing is an attribute) normally don’t take “the” – Moraine Lake, Rainbow Falls, Happy Valley, Cougar Mountain, etc. So if it’s a valley first, it’s likely to be X Valley, whereas if it’s a river or whatever first and the valley is an attribute of it – if it’s the valley of the X – then it may be the X Valley.

But the main reason that Silicon Valley doesn’t take a the is just because it doesn’t. Never mind arguing from reasoning; place names are varied enough that exceptions can typically be found for any rule. Place names adhere to what is actually officially and commonly used for the place name, and it is not officially or commonly standard to say or write the Silicon Valley. It’s like saying the New York or the Vancouver Island.

About these ads

3 responses to “Why not the Silicon Valley?

  1. When Fairchild Semiconductor moved its headquarters from Maine earlier this year, the Portland (Maine) Press Herald wrote up the story.

    I was amused by how the writer/editor amended this quote:
    “All the engineers are in (the) Silicon Valley. Thompson is from (the) Silicon Valley. All the other chip firms are there. Why does Fairchild need to stay in Maine? … To me, it just makes sense to be in the hub of activity.”

    http://www.pressherald.com/business/Fairchild-moving-HQ-to-Silicon-Valley.html

    • Oh, man. Correcting quotes for any reason other than ambiguity is obnoxious (e.g., using “sic” after grammatical errors that will not lead to misunderstanding and will not be mistaken for a typo of the quoter); doing so when you’re wrong is obnoxious squared.

  2. Pingback: Good Reads | Cornucopia Creations

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s